Hollis Beckwith, a senior with anxiety, is in a comfortable relationship with Chris. To prove her worth, she learns Chris’s favorite game, Secrets & Sorcery, but has to join an all-girls group due to his “No Girlfriends at the Table” rule. In this group, Hollis grows as a person and forms a deep connection with Aini Amin-Shaw, leading her to question her desires and her relationship with Chris.